Sanibel's Best Homemade Ice Cream

$
Closed
yelp logo

(69)

Photos

362 Periwinkle Way
Sanibel, FL 33957

Specialties

The popular ice cream shop, known for many years on Sanibels East End, continues to focus on handcrafted products and unique presentations. When the name changed both Laurie and Alice wanted to take this almost perfect ice cream and make it BETTER! One may ask, How could this possibly be accomplished?? Well this is how it happenedLaurie asked a true and dear friend, (also in the ice cream industry) Mrs. Mandy McGovern for an expert Ice Cream maker suggestion then hired this expert (40+ years) from Meadville, PA to fly down to Sanibel and teach all how to make a better (if not perfect) Homemade Ice Cream. We studied, practiced, removed the artificial base and increased the milk fat content to make a more natural, no artificial ice cream base which results in a creamier (no more icicles), smoother, tastier product! This is what we wanted from the very beginningand now its happening!! The results are:

Reviews

yelp logo
4.069 reviews
Dale B.
6/23/2025

Also know as Magic Bus. We each had different flavors of the homemade ice cream and all of us were appreciative of the quality and service!

Photo of Mercedes C.
Mercedes C.
8/13/2022

In spite of the previous ice cream business (Pinocchio's) shipping out of this same exact spot and making way for the current Sanibel's Best, it's truly nostalgia for us to come here and support...

Photo of ann marie c.
ann marie c.
5/9/2024

Very good homemade ice cream Clean Fun flavors Fun colors And 21 and up liquior ice cream

Mag S.
1/2/2025

This place is a hidden gem! What a great place! Their ice cream's flavors are out of this world. They have sucha variety to choose from and they even have alcohol infused ice cream! Everything is...

Photo of Jacqueline T.
Jacqueline T.
12/10/2021

We love trying local ice cream shops so we had to check this place out since it was on the same street we stayed on. We got 3 scoops: - The Beautiful Juanita (Almond/Amaretto) - Island Time...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaSanibelSanibel's Best Homemade Ice Cream

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.