Cissy W.
9/13/2025
We found this Seafood Market and went for Shrimp, local shrimp. Got the "Mayport Shrimp" and were not disappointed. Had to peel and devein but worth the effort. Nice selection of other seafood...
Reel Deal Seafood
Closed
(16)
Photos
6373 A1A S
Saint Augustine, FL 32080
Reel Deal Seafood is a quaint eatery nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, FL, known for its fresh seafood offerings and casual dining atmosphere.
With a focus on quality ingredients and simple preparations, Reel Deal Seafood provides a taste of the sea in a relaxed setting for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.016 reviews
Jill H.
6/28/2025
Our new seafood go to! We have been twice in two days! Today was shrimp we turned into Alfredo and yesterday we got mangrove snapper, grouper, and flounder. All delicious and the staff is a wealth...
Daniel B.
11/16/2023
There's a not-quite-so-new anymore fish market on the south side of Saint Augustine... and it's magnificent! Well, I should say it is small but it is might. Previously I had sworn my allegiance...
Frugal And Practical P.
3/19/2025
Shrimp is neither fresh nor local. Tried this place based on glowing YELP reviews and let me tell you, I am VERY disappointed in my fellow yelpers for leading me astray. **When you post a glowing...
Tricia L.
8/20/2025
Feb & March 25 we frequented the Reel Deal. The seafood was excellent and very fresh. They know their product and prepare a few specially seasoned, just pop it in the oven or on the grill items....
See a problem?
