Taffy O.
8/4/2025
Best meal in Key west . Shrimp mango toast excellent. Seafood medley was to die for. Grouper was very good. Service was excellent . Definitely get a reservation .. awesome
Red Shoe Island Bistro
$
Closed
(320)
Photos
411 Petronia St
Key West, FL 33040
Key West seafood is served in a relaxed atmosphere. Yellowtail snapper, Key West shrimp, scallops, beef stroganoff, toasted mango bread topped with Key West shrimp, seasonal veggies, and the best Key Lime pie. Gluten-free menu items. We offer two seatings: 6 pm & 8 pm. In the interest of our guests, we do not accept reservations over 6 people and we do not have a kids menu.
Also at this address
Reviews
5.0320 reviews
David B.
9/4/2025
Best meal I had in Key West! #1. John, my waiter, was excellent. His knowledge of the menu was spectacular. #2. Started with the shrimp mango toast at John's recommendation ("like crack on a...
Vivian R.
8/7/2025
Stepped off a sea plane and was hunkering for some dinner with my family. Found this open rezy away from Duval and decided to try it. Did not disappoint. Food - so delish. Their key lime pie is...
Chris H.
7/20/2025
We went to Red Shoe Island Bistro for their 5th anniversary and had an incredible experience. The service was excellent and the food was phenomenal from start to finish. We started with the...
Brittany N.
6/4/2025
Pros: Location was great. Everywhere on the island was very walkable. Ambiance is wonderful. Very dimly lit. Very romantic. A lovely candlelit dinner. Service was great. The guy was very nice,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.