Urmilla S.
7/18/2025
This ice Cream shop is the best. I had 2 scoops of coffee and hazelnut gelato, bring back memories of Italy. The ceiling was like a summer and winter wonderland. It was amazing. The staff was...
Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream
$$
Closed
(27)
Photos
2075 Periwinkle Way Ste 33
Sanibel, FL 33957
Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream, a beloved establishment in Sanibel, FL, is renowned for its fun and unique flavors, showcasing a philosophy that encourages indulging in sweet treats without restraint. For over 20 years, each ice cream product has been topped with a whimsical Animal Cracker, adding a playful touch to their delicious offerings.
Founded by the Puma family, Pinocchio's prides itself on creating memorable experiences through its artisanal ice cream. Their commitment to quality and creativity has made them a local favorite, inviting both residents and visitors to savor the joy of Italian ice cream.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.527 reviews
Paul S.
8/28/2025
"Fun " and delicious ice cream. Service was friendly and fast. If you're looking for ice cream. This is the place!
Ken K.
2/1/2025
Outstanding ice cream... some of the best ever. Nice shop, good service and lots of great flavors. I got cherry chocolate chip (called Love Bug)... and I'm a confident man that can admit this
Carolyn J.
6/16/2024
Real Sanibel-ITES know Pinocchio's is an old classic- I've been going since I was a kid. It's now open in the sadly a bit desolate Periwinkle Plaza, but I know more stores will reopen soon. The...
Laura E.
3/29/2024
Such a great location for an ice cream shop! They have a tiny inside store and a few tables outside. The line looks intimidating but it moves quick! The flavors were kind of hit or miss. I wish...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.