Daren R.
8/29/2025
Told by a Cape Coral local guy to try this pizza spot in Pine Island near Matlache. I passed by it several times and noticed that the front of the building advertises pizza slices, so immediately...
Pine Island Pizza
$
Closed
(47)
Photos
5465 Pine Island Rd NW
Bokeelia, FL 33922
Pine Island Pizza offers a variety of pizzas in a friendly atmosphere. Known for their delicious food, the restaurant has gained popularity among locals and visitors alike for its inviting service. Many customers choose Pine Island Pizza as their go-to lunch spot, especially after church services.
The restaurant prides itself on quality pizza crafted by skilled chefs. With a welcoming staff, Pine Island Pizza aims to create a positive dining experience for all who visit. Their commitment to good food and community makes them a valued choice in the area.
Generated from the web
Reviews
3.547 reviews
Sylvia H.
9/4/2025
Bring back the fountain drinks, that's what makes the pizza experience better. The food is good it could be better. The service by some staff is terrible no people manners, not as friendly as it...
Porsche O.
8/9/2025
Soggy undercooked crust. Paucity of cheese and sauce. Low quality room temperature toppings that seemingly were added after the pie came out of the oven. In short the worst pizza I've had in my 75...
Shelby S.
7/19/2025
This place is always a "good" place for pizza on the Island. However, it's run by a bunch a loud kids and that makes it hard to just relax and eat your meal. Forget trying to call and order...
Anthony S.
10/19/2024
This pizza spot was the closest we've found to the taste of pizza in the northeast. The owner sold the restaurant a couple years ago and I believe the previous owners son stayed on board and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.