Jeff L.
8/13/2025
I've been wanting to try this for a year or more - tonight was my lucky night. Had a bad experience with the El Camino Taco Truck at Perfect Plain so we were in search of some dinner when left...
Papa’s Pizza Downtown
Closed
(53)
Photos
18 E Garden St
Pensacola, FL 32502
Papa’s Pizza Downtown in Pensacola, FL, has been serving up authentic New York style pizzas since 1947. Their menu features a variety of specialty pizzas like The Frank Sinatra with pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, and more, as well as by-the-slice options for a quick bite. Customers can also enjoy salads, calzones, strombolis, and pasta dishes.
With a commitment to quality, Papa’s Pizza Downtown prepares their sauce and dough fresh daily, using only the finest Italian cheeses. Whether you're craving a classic cheese pizza or a gourmet creation like The Joe Pesci with sun-dried tomatoes and artichoke hearts, there's something for every pizza lover to enjoy at this iconic establishment.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.053 reviews
Edjaniel S.
8/4/2025
Had a different pizza spot every day while visiting Pensacola, and this was my second favorite after Lost Pizza Co. The pepperoni pizza was delicious- I'd definitely grab it again. I can only...
Caitlyn C.
4/20/2025
This is a pretty cool spot. Definitely has New York/Chicago vibes with the exposed brick, baseball on tv, and of course, the pizza! Service was ok, but it's also the reason I'm bumping my rating...
Larry B.
9/10/2025
Decent for panhandle style No real ny style available in Pensacola beach area A real shame
Zane C.
9/6/2025
Great East coast style pizza. New York / Boston style. Nice and cool inside. Very friendly staff. Pizza by the slice too. Great price point for good pizza.
See a problem?
