Tom T.
5/12/2025
The closest thing to New York style pizza you will get in central Florida. Absolutely delicious!!!
Papa Joe's Pizza
$
Open
(134)
Photos
960 Colonial Grand Ln
Lake Mary, FL 32746
Papa Joe's Pizza is a cozy eatery nestled in Lake Mary, FL, offering a delectable selection of Italian cuisine to satisfy any craving. The menu features mouth-watering pizzas made fresh from the oven, tantalizing pasta dishes with homemade sauces, and a variety of secret spices to enhance every bite.
With a commitment to quality, Papa Joe's Pizza provides the option for both takeout and dine-in experiences, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite dishes however they please. Boasting two convenient locations in Seminole County, including Altamonte and Heathrow, this family-owned establishment welcomes guests seven days a week.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
3.5134 reviews
Eric R.
2/13/2025
Ordered and asked for grubhub delivery. It's been 1-1/2 hrs. Don't do it. Great pizza but only go in person or pick up
Jeremy O.
1/5/2025
They've got some good lunch deals. I'd order ahead, as they make their dishes fresh (took a little while, but worth it). It's nestled behind all the action so it's easy to miss this quaint spot....
Cindy K.
7/19/2025
16" Cheese Pizza with 1 side mushroom, 1 side sausage. The crust was stale and dry with very little pizza sauce.
Carla S.
3/9/2023
I have been wanted to try Papa Joe's for a while. It is always packed and that means something. While I Also, while Iwas dining pizza pick ups were non-stop. I was craving Italian food before...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.