Maria B.
7/31/2025
Wow! The Carne Asada was out of this world - perfectly tender and flavorful. The rice and beans were so tasty, and my husband and I ended up sharing (even though he wasn't too hungry, he couldn't...
Old Town Mexican Cafe
$$
Open
(525)
Photos
609 Duval St
Key West, FL 33040
Welcome to Old Town Mexican Caf and Tequila Bar, home of Chef Gail Brockway's award-winning fresh take on the Southwest cuisine inspired by New Mexican foods of Sante Fe and authentic Mexican cuisine. If you're looking for something extraordinary and an alternative to Mexican food's typical Tex-Mex style, then look no further than Old Town Mexican Caf. We still offer Mexican food favorites like tacos, burritos, and tostadas, all with Chef Gail's signature, southwestern flair.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5525 reviews
Annie S.
7/4/2025
Grouper tacos are fishy Salsa too hot Soda is flat Bean and rice stale Guacamole from a container
Hayley G.
6/20/2025
Great place to kick back with some Mexican food and margaritas in a classic Key West setting. We came to catch one of our teams play and had a great time snacking on chips and salsa while cheering...
Michele Marie F.
5/25/2025
My daughter and I were looking for something delicious but not as loud and crazy as many places in Key west tend to be. We were definitely happy with our dinner here! The drinks were wonderful I...
Jay T.
2/20/2025
As I do not think about Mexican food when visiting Key West, we have always walked past this restaurant. What an error on our part. The food and service was outstanding. Our server Candice was...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.