Rachel M.
6/7/2025
Can't believe this was the first time we had ice cream here. This was great local Amish Ice Cream made by Yoder's. Which you can also visit in Sarasota. I tried several flavors including Key...
Olaf's Siesta Village
$$
Closed
(24)
Photos
5208 Ocean Blvd
Sarasota, FL 34242
Olaf’s Siesta Village was established in 1982 and has been family owned ever since. That's over 41 years spent serving up cones, sundaes, milkshakes, malts, smoothies, fudge and more to the community! ...and we loved every minute of it. Olaf’s is nestled in the heart of Siesta Village and has been a tradition since opening. We serve delicious Yoder’s Southern Creamery, old-fashioned ice cream made locally here in Sarasota.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.524 reviews
Nicole F.
7/19/2025
I love a good cup of ice cream after a stroll on the beach. Cute ice cream shop with a smell of homemade waffle cones you can smell a Mike away. It's minutes away from the beach. So many flavors...
Laura F.
7/14/2025
After 20 years of visit after visit. I finally had a good ice cream here. I always thought this place was overrated, but it didn't stop me from continuing to go year after year after year. I never...
Hayley A.
5/26/2025
We stopped here after eating pizza a few stores down and was not disappointed. We were all super full but still wanted to try some ice cream in town. I got the double chocolate fudge ice cream and...
Olivia B.
12/29/2024
You can tell Olaf's is a classic spot because of the long line! Everyone wants to get a scoop! Since we were waiting in the line, I wish I could see the flavors and menu sooner to be more...
See a problem?
