Josh K.
8/22/2025
Fantastic location, but they drastically reduced the size of the garlic knots, which is a major drawback. I still adore them, but they aren't as fluffy inside.
NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria
$$
Open
(231)
Photos
1075 Oakleaf Plantation Pkwy
Orange Park, FL 32065
NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria is a popular dining destination in Jacksonville and St. Augustine, Florida, offering authentic NYC-style cuisine in a modern atmosphere. The menu features a diverse selection of fresh pizza, pasta, meatballs, wings, and salads, complemented by a range of beer, wine, and spirits.
Dedicated to providing a clean and inviting environment, NYC Meatballs caters to the sophisticated tastes of its neighborhood clientele. With a commitment to quality and community, the restaurant is poised to expand with new locations in Orange Park and St. Augustine, enhancing its reach and culinary offerings.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0231 reviews
Omayra Aka Myra J.
9/1/2025
Wow... that's all I can say! Ambiance was great when we walked in. The bar tender (Meg) was AMAZING. Let's talk drinks. I ordered a Hugo spritz and hubby ordered a Mitchers Old fashioned....
Clay S.
9/25/2025
Where to begin, let's start super positive! It's a very small spot but also feels very intimate. The bar is large and the people are super friendly! Service is amazing. What we had: wife had...
Jeanne L.
7/13/2025
Our server had crazy good customer service skills. She brought drinks and apps out fast and kept us informed of the progess of the three pizzas and wings. She was mindful of not setting hot...
Sheila W.
8/30/2025
This is our first time trying pizzeria and also our last time. We order large meat lovers, medium margherita and 10 pieces regular wings for $62. Our order was not put into the system correctly,...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.