Nostalgia Pizza Shop

Open
yelp logo

(3)

Call

Photos

38426 5th Ave
Zephyrhills, FL 33542
+1 (813) 355-4076

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.53 reviews
Corbin S.
10/16/2025

Great pizza. Can be pretty greasy on the top, but the flavors are fantastic, I think it's their tomato sauce. Lots of flop in the undercarriage, but still a fantastic pizza, very flavorful. The...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Carol T.
Carol T.
8/10/2025

New pizza restaurant on 5th avenue in downtown Zephyrhills. Slices and soda for $4.00. Nice place to sit and eat lunch. Very good customer service and clean place to eat. I'll return. Good...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Susie M.
Susie M.
9/19/2025

Nostalgia Pizza is awesome! We got "The Works" and another half pepperoni/half mushroom and both were delicious. Crust was perfect, toppings were fresh and generous, and it really hit the spot....

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Zephyrhills Eagles 3752

1
"It's closed permanently they lost their lease I heard and haven't heard any new developments"
photo of Jodi N.
Slice Of The Hillz
Eating places

Slice Of The Hillz

28
"It's a "Mom and Pop" CiCi's Pizza. Small pies constantly coming out hot and fresh. If you want something specific you can order it at the register and it will be brought to your table. The..."
photo of Jennifer D.
Domino's Pizza
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Domino's Pizza

24
•
$
"I have always had a good experience with the rewards app but recently it wasn't taking my card on file so I called the restaurant and neil answered the phone he was so helpful and even did a one..."
United States›Florida›Nostalgia Pizza Shop