Coley M.
6/13/2025
Food great service great We were traveling and after a long day of driving this was perfect.
New York Pizza
$
Closed
(98)
Photos
1811 Golden Eagle Way
Fleming Island, FL 32003
New York Pizza in Fleming Island, Florida, is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, renowned for its perfectly thin crust and generous layers of cheese. Patrons rave about the extensive menu, which includes pizza rolls and chicken wings, all crafted with a focus on quality and flavor.
With a reputation for excellent customer service, the restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming atmosphere, making it a favored choice for both locals and visitors. Reviewers consistently highlight their positive dining experiences, solidifying New York Pizza as a go-to spot on Fleming Island.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.098 reviews
Alysha G.
12/4/2024
As soon as me and my son walked in we got greeted and let us know where the menu was. There was a few slices they had sold per slice in the case but everything else is made to order. The wait...
Josh R.
4/19/2025
The New York Pizza in Fleming Island, FL makes claim to having the most authentic NY style pizza in a North Florida. And let me tell you, the pizza is massive, like its flavors. The sauce is...
Lilscrappyd D.
8/27/2025
They get zero stars not only because of their pizza and wings but because the person answering the phone couldn't even apologize for the food being cold! She actually was arguing with the...
Garry H.
6/9/2025
The New York pizza was not good, taste sauce and crust .........I don't recommend this pizza. The owner can contact me and I can help them get their product right!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.