Lalit P.
2/28/2025
Best place to visit on winter time Nice and clean environment Good food We will be back
Mystic Lobster of Marco Island
Permanently closed
(16)
Photos
1035 N Collier Blvd
Marco Island, FL 34145
Mystic Lobster is a quaint seafood restaurant nestled in the heart of Marco Island, FL.
Specializing in fresh lobster dishes and other seafood delicacies, the restaurant offers a cozy dining experience for locals and tourists alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.016 reviews
Mike R.
9/2/2025
BEWARE: Permanently closed, but their website is still up and taking online orders... that you can't ever pick up. Reported as closed to Yelp - hopefully it updates soon.
Eneida Q.
8/1/2024
Check out their coupons on their paper menus! I saw them after I paid. Really good! Fresh lobster. Prices are fair, given the market price for lobster. The sizes are fair too with all that...
Ashley H.
7/24/2024
A lobster roll for everyone! This new business is delicious!of course there is the typical choices, but they've added different types and different sizes. The rolls are made fresh to order and...
Ferg A.
7/2/2024
Was vacationing at Marco island for A week and I wanted something light and fresh and this little place didn't Disappoint!!! The lobster roll, the roll with shrimps and the Mac and cheese with...
See a problem?
