Kristine O.
8/9/2025
The best key lime pie ice cream I ever had. The ambiance was very fun. They had a dude playing guitar and singing Beetles music. Good family fun.
Mystic Ice Cream
Closed
(9)
Photos
441 N US-27
Lady Lake, FL 32159
Mystic Ice Cream is a charming ice cream shop nestled in the heart of Lady Lake, FL.
Offering a variety of delicious ice cream flavors and sweet treats, it provides a delightful experience for customers of all ages.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.09 reviews
Jackie L.
8/17/2025
The most basic flavors and very over priced. This place is purely vibes. Won't go back or recommend.
Teri S.
9/30/2025
Love the fun boho musical vibe. The ice cream is simply the best! My faves are Cherry Amaretto and Maple Bourbon Pecan! And I n the summer there's nothing like the Lemon Blueberry Sorbet. I always...
Diane W.
5/30/2024
Our first visit to this Mystic location, what a unique vibe! They offer classic homemade ice cream varieties & also adults only if you are looking for a kick up on your ice cream. We stayed with...
Brie D.
7/3/2024
Great place for traditional or specialty ice cream flavors! Highly recommend. Wonderful staff. Awesome 50s,60s & 70s ambiance. Great date place. They have adult flavors based off mixed drinks....
See a problem?
