Andrew B.
11/9/2025
Awesome location, flavors and great dairy free options which is somewhat uncommon on the island! Been here a few times and hope the place sticks.
Mr Bentley’s Ice Cream Shop
Closed
(9)
Photos
1035 N Collier Blvd
Marco Island, FL 34145
Mr Bentley’s Ice Cream Shop located in the sunny paradise of Marco Island FL is a delightful destination for ice cream lovers. Offering a wide variety of creamy flavors and delicious toppings this charming shop invites you to indulge in a sweet treat while enjoying the coastal atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a classic scoop or a unique creation Mr Bentley’s is sure to satisfy your cravings and bring a smile to your face.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
5.09 reviews
Cesar A.
7/11/2025
Great ice cream parlor with traditional and a few other unique flavors. Small and worth the wait, the staff the was great and the ice cream better.
Anthony B.
12/26/2023
Read about this new ice cream shop in the Marco paper, and wanted to try it. Came here after driving on the island to do the annual Christmas light tour. The flavor selection is great, they have...
Matthew S.
4/18/2025
Best ice cream on the island! The lemon Oreo, cookie butter or the dozen other original flavors make this place stand out as original and locally made with no artificial dyes. First Place!
Maggie D.
7/18/2024
We had the coffee cookie, praline cream, chocolate, mint chip, and nutter butter. All the flavors were very good. I wouldn't say it was great or make a point to go back but it was good.
See a problem?
