Erica M.
10/31/2025
1. Key lime hands-down, one of the best Keylime pies that I have ever had. The crust was buttery, but it also had like a granola with pecans in it. Oh my God it was absolutely delicious. The key...
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
$$
Closed
(166)
Photos
440 W Adams St
Jacksonville, FL 32202
Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is a quaint bakery in Jacksonville, FL that specializes in crafting a variety of delicious pies.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques, they offer a selection of sweet and savory pies to satisfy every palate.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
5.0166 reviews
Olivia G.
7/15/2025
Best Pie, Best Vibe, Best Humans, Creative, Loving, Fun, Sassy, Giving, Amazing Community Connectivity, Accepting, Passionate, Generous, Professional, Witty, Charming, Experienced, Outstanding...
Whitney D.
6/14/2025
Update 6/14/25: THEY have a NEW location! It's downtown across from the courthouse. If you have any questions check out their IG for all info including on parking. The pie always slaps here. I...
David A.
4/21/2025
We recently placed an advanced order for a pie done only for special occasions. The Head Honcho. We picked it up at the charming new location in downtown Jax. I'm truly glad they've found a great...
Mandie M.
1/25/2025
*Quick Note*: just because this location is closed doesn't mean that Mixing Fillings is closed! You can preorder pies and pick them up currently on Saturdays at Riverside Arts Market! There is a...
See a problem?
