Başak O.
5/23/2025
I really like the ice cream! I took coconut roasted and chocolate. Homemade and fresh ice cream. Aida who look after us was so nice and kind
Mattheessen's
$
Closed
(139)
Photos
106 Duval St
Key West, FL 33040
Fresh cookies, fudge, key lime pie and ice cream! All products made from scratch in our store. Come by and taste some deliciousness!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5139 reviews
Monic S.
6/30/2025
My kids say this is the best ice cream they have ever had. The chocolate dipped key like pie was so good too!
Sheri M.
6/12/2025
Freshly squeezed lemonade for me in the door, but the homemade giant chocolate chip & pecan cookie with warm ice cream made us stay. The shop is located in the middle of a busy (even on a...
Lisa S.
8/13/2025
Homemade ice cream and huge delicious cookies. THE BEST! A must visit. Right across the street from La Concha hotel.
Andrew M.
9/5/2025
The best ice cream on the island. Been here a long time and owner is a great down to earth guy.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.