Main Street Creamery

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(132)

Photos

1359 Main St
Sarasota, FL 34236
"Made in small batches right here in Sarasota, our nationally acclaimed and award winning ice cream is the creamiest ice cream in Florida. Every cone, cup, and shake is made with ice cream from our partners at Yoder’s Southern Creamery."

Reviews

yelp logo
5.0132 reviews
Photo of Anne-Mary P.
Anne-Mary P.
11/9/2025

What a great find. Seating inside at table and chairs or at the bar in the window as well as tables outside! Dairy free options available and not just plain vanilla and chocolate flavors! Any ice...

Photo of Joshua S.
Joshua S.
7/6/2025

Run, Don't Walk to Main Street Creamery! Run, don't walk to Main Street Creamery -- this place is a gem! No matter where you're from, you'll love it here. The staff is super friendly and you can...

Photo of Dan M.
Dan M.
5/28/2025

This was a shop that served locally made flavors. The fascinating detail about this was that any flavor could be churned into a soft serve when ordering. They had lots of flavors, and the...

Photo of Lynn N.
Lynn N.
10/24/2025

This ice cream creamery was delicious! When we walked in and saw how many flavors they had, we wanted to sample them all. The place is very bright with walls detailing their ice cream and flavors....

Photo of Paris T.
Paris T.
8/6/2025

I have been visiting different ice cream shops all summer and Main Street Creamery might be my favorite so far! The employees were very friendly and we got to sample a few flavors before deciding...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaSarasotaMain Street Creamery

Partial Data by Foursquare.