Dee M.
8/10/2025
I thought I posted this years ago, but just found it in my drafts. Key Lime Pie Only Review This was the best out of 9 places we went to in Key West for Key Lime Pie. Key Lime Pie Review...
Key West Key Lime Pie Company
$$
Open
(534)
Photos
511 Greene St
Key West, FL 33040
Key West Key Lime Pie Company's pies are made fresh daily using all-natural ingredients, real key lime juice, and a handmade graham cracker crust. Our pies are the perfect amount of sweet and tart! Stop by for a slice, a pie, or a delicious chocolate-dipped bar - seating is available so you can relax after a long day in Key West. Better yet, join us for a pie-making class where you can go behind-the-scenes and make your very own mini key lime pie in our kitchen! Our store also features delicious Sweet Pete's candies and confections. You will love the famous sea salt caramel - make sure to taste a sample! Come visit us on Greene St or check out our website.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0534 reviews
Matt C.
7/22/2025
Though I had my doubts from the name and branding, this was one of the memorable key lime pies I had on my vacation. Glad it lived up to the name! I'm not knocking the name, but when you're...
Stacey P.
5/4/2025
Key lime pie in Key West is an absolute must. It was amazing. We went to the Key West Key Like Pie Company because Skipper from Hemingway recommended it and if I am visiting a city and a local...
Carolyn J.
8/25/2025
As one does in Key West, we meandered past this place and decided to try it. The inside is cute and kitschy. The young man at the register helped us out. I got the "crustless" key lime cup and it...
Taylor B.
8/13/2025
Sooo good! We got the pie in a cup and it was so custardy and key limey. I would definitely return!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.