Johnny Tomatoes Pizza

There are no words. Run, don't walk to Johnny Tomatoes! We ordered way too much because we had to try all the things. Garlic knots 10/10 melt in your mouth amazing. Cheese pizza 10/10 and kid...

September 21, 2025 - Two for take out, first visit. More of a test trail run and I should probably had tried the plain cheese pizza as the defacto standard for pizza joints of course. However...

First time there, and as a Chicago pizza snob I'm hard to please. That said, I thought the pizza was excellent! Personally I like a little more cheese and sauce, but the flavors were outstanding....

We have lived here for four years and finally found a good pizza, not to mention the garlic knots. Ordered sausage, mushroom, margarita and white chicken. All excellent, best garlic knots I ever...

We're from the NJ/NY area and are so happy to have found pizza that tastes like home while in FL. We devoured the 24 inch margarita pie! The loads of fresh basil and olive oil drizzle sealed the deal.