Island Pizza

We came here because it's advertised as the best pizza on the island but we were pleasantly surprised to find that their chicken wings were absolutely amazing! They were crispy and delicious and...

2.9 stars for this place is ridiculous. It's pizza and you're on an island. Set your expectations accordingly. It's decent. Not the best pizza you'll ever eat, but good enough if you're in the...

We came here and dined in recently while visiting family on Sanibel. The pizza itself was quite tasty, if greasy, and the chicken wings were excellent! We also had a caesar salad to share. The...

Ordered our first night on Sanibel after a long travel day. Very mediocre and expensive. Would not order again.

I'm confused about the negative reviews. This place was great! Our waitress made sure our drinks were full and was very attentive. Zero complaints. We ordered a large Hogs-N-Horns and a large...