Zoe W.
6/17/2025
Great pizza! I wasn't expecting much, but was pleasantly surprised by how good our pie was (and that's coming from a CT pizza fan). We decided on the "Pepe" pizza. The ratio of sauce to cheese was...
Islamorada Pizza
Closed
(15)
Photos
84341 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036
Islamorada Pizza Co. is a vibrant pizza restaurant located in the heart of Islamorada, Florida, offering a diverse menu that includes whole pies, pizza by the slice, and a variety of snacks and salads. Known for their unique pizza creations, such as the Carnivore and Nonna, the establishment also features an arcade for added entertainment.
In addition to their delicious food, Islamorada Pizza Co. provides a selection of beverages, including local craft beers and wines, making it a perfect spot for both casual dining and special events. With a commitment to quality and a fun atmosphere, it’s a popular destination for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.515 reviews
Taylor, Realtor E.
1/5/2025
Review for Islamorada Pizza Co - A Must-Try Spot in the Keys! We had the pleasure of trying Islamorada Pizza Co, the new pizza spot just outside of 3 Waters Resort in Islamorada, and it...
Mary S.
12/24/2024
I was craving a cheesy pizza.... I saw like the pics of the all cheese pizza here, but there were only a few reviews, so I was nervous, but I went for it and OMG it was sooooo delicious. The spot...
Steve B.
9/24/2025
The food was so-so. That being the pizza. We also tried a salad. I was not very impressed with the salad as far as freshness would be considered. The lettuce was soft and limp and too much...
Larry R.
11/27/2024
This is a brand new place, right down the street from us, in the Keys. I was concerned that it would be any good at all, but I was in for a surprise..... absolutely great !! Very tasty , crispy,...
See a problem?
