Elizabeth H.
10/18/2025
A wonderful, family owned ice cream shop hidden in the middle of a strip mall near Publix. The staff was sweet as was the ice cream! I had gator trax and would highly recommend it. Between all the...
Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop
$
Closed
(163)
Photos
3234 E Bay Dr
Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Located in Holmes Beach, FL, Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop offers a delightful array of frozen treats on Anna Maria Island. This family-run establishment boasts 36 ice cream flavors, including options such as dairy-free, vegan, and sugar-free varieties, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.
Visitors can indulge in a custom ice cream experience, with choices ranging from classic cones to milkshakes, malts, and sundaes made from the freshest ingredients. The soft serve, which is freshly prepared each day, is a particular favorite among patrons, especially when paired with decadent toppings like hot fudge or butterscotch.
With rave reviews from satisfied customers praising the extensive flavor selection and warm hospitality, Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop promises a welcoming atmosphere where guests can savor their favorite frozen treats while feeling right at home.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
4.5163 reviews
Ronald S.
3/17/2025
Family owned business. A little bit funny ordering with children because the children are not allowed to order. Only the adults for the kids. A rule probably from many years of getting gibberish...
Sarah T.
11/1/2025
They had great ice cream and also satisfied our need for gluten free ice cream cones! We were so grateful that they were accommodating to our dietary needs in addition to being delicious!
Teresa G.
5/15/2025
Great ice cream! Very friendly family staff and they help the community by collecting donations. I got a milk shake & it was excellent! My friends got scoops with various sprinkles, they loved...
Haley R.
6/25/2024
Such a cute family owned shop. We stopped in last year and had to come back again! Delicious selection of ice creams and choices on how to enjoy it. The owners are so friendly and offer great...
See a problem?
