Jake L.
8/4/2025
I got the Redneck Rueben and my girlfriend got the Short Rib Mac N Cheese both were insanely good and very unique. I added their mustang bbq sauce on top of the rueben and it made it even better...
Herbie's Bar & Chowder House
$$
Closed
(639)
Photos
6350 Overseas Hwy
Marathon, FL 33050
Herbies is the oldest operating restaurant in the Heart of the Florida Keys! Having been established in the late 1940's under the name Maggie's Chowder House, it has become a landmark restaurant and continued local favorite. While the restaurant is well established, the only thing old school about the menu is the fact that everything is prepared from scratch here, and that includes grinding our own grass fed beef, conch, sausage, and hot dogs (when available). And, our beer selection is unmatched from Miami to Key West. All on tap craft beer. No, you will not find a National branded beer here, but you will find true American fresh craft beer along with some exceptionally fine wines all poured by the glass. So, don't let the Florida road side shack appearance fool you! Come on in and enjoy some of the best food in the Heart of the Keys!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5639 reviews
Sana S.
8/29/2025
Everywhere in the Keys tends to serve up a similar style of food, but Herbie's really stands out by adding their own twist. The poutine brisket fries were exceptional, rich, hearty, and packed...
Sam H.
6/25/2025
I had the fish and chips. Mahi seems to be the go to fish. While good, I prefer cod. The breading was actually a little light for me. I prefer light breading, but this was really light. But the...
Michael S.
3/18/2025
This was the perfect lunch! The set up is a bit confusing-- there are two indoor seating areas (each with their own bar) and a third outdoor patio, though each is accessed from separate doors....
Madelyn A.
7/5/2025
Herbie's is always a must stop in the Keys. We tried the hot honey shrimp app and it was really crispy and flavorful. The chicken and smashed potato is always sooo good. I tried the Asian tacos...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.