Georgeann M.
6/23/2025
Grandma Penny knocked it outta the park with her handmade crust! We ordered a large sausage, ricotta, and basil pie and decided we're making the hour trip to come back again. We live in Sarasota...
Grandma Penny's Pizza
$
Closed
(43)
Photos
4353 Hancock Bridge Pkwy
North Fort Myers, FL 33903
Welcome to Grandma Penny’s Pizza Pasta, Wings, and more a family-owned gem nestled in the heart of North Fort Myers. We are proud to bring the authentic flavors of New York-style pizza and traditional Italian cuisine to our community. Our passion for food is rooted in family traditions, and we’re dedicated to sharing these delicious recipes with you. At Grandma Penny’s, we specialize in NY Style Brick Oven Pizzas, Pasta Dinners, Fresh Subs, Salads, Calzones, Stromboli, and more. Whether you’re looking for a cozy dine-in experience, a quick takeout option, or convenient delivery, we’ve got you covered. We partner with SLICE, Uber Eats, and DoorDash to bring our mouthwatering dishes straight to your door within a 5-mile radius. Our inviting dining room is perfect for everyone—whether you’re gathering with friends, celebrating with your team, or enjoying a family night out. With bar seating and large high-definition TVs, you can catch your favorite game while savoring our signature
Also at this address
Reviews
4.543 reviews
Don R.
9/22/2024
This location has been recommended to me by a few friends so we took the opportunity to visit and give it a go! The location is quite spacious and can easily accommodate large family events or a...
Lauren H.
3/26/2025
Not bad! Not bad at all. I appreciate a good lunch deal. Two slices of cheese and a pop for $7. My coworkers ordered a great looking salad and a sub. Good service! We were in and out under an...
Terry L.
9/29/2024
Grandma Penny's Pizza 9-26-24 We arrived there around 12:30 on a day where Hurricane Helene is only about 170 mile off the coast. They were not that busy, just a couple booths and some people at...
Daniel L.
11/15/2024
Stopped in for a late lunch. I asked if they had slices, she said they ended at four. Understandable- I am just one person and cannot eat a large pie. She said she would accommodate me and I...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.