Scott P.
4/17/2025
This is without a doubt the best home style neighborhood Italian pizza shop south of Philadelphia / New Jersey. The staff - awesome. Friendly, efficient, treat you like family. The Food -...
Goodfellas Pizzeria
Closed
(28)
Photos
4932 W State Road 46 Ste 1060
Sanford, FL 32771
Goodfellas Pizzeria in Sanford, FL, is a family-owned establishment dedicated to delivering an unforgettable dining experience with a focus on New York-style pizza and authentic Italian dishes. Using the highest quality products and the freshest ingredients, the Ciaccio family pours their heart and soul into every meal served, ensuring a warm and welcoming atmosphere for all guests.
In addition to traditional hand-tossed pizzas, Goodfellas offers mouthwatering pasta dishes and lunch specials, showcasing their commitment to exceptional service and culinary passion. The restaurant's dedication to community is evident, as they extend a 10% discount to law enforcement personnel as a gesture of appreciation for their service.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.528 reviews
David R.
10/6/2025
Not my first time here. Pizza is always good and that garlic oil is off the chain. Had wings this time around. I always call ahead before picking up my order because I never know what the...
Elaine B.
9/23/2025
Goodfellas...what can I say. A 5-star staple in and around Orlando for 30+ years. The garlic knots are the best. The pizza is undeniable. A++ Italian
Caroline B.
8/16/2025
Got pizza from goodfellas last night. It was pretty decent. It was like a 6-7/10. I would say the lack of sauce was disappointing but other than that, the pizza was delicious! It was a great new...
Priscilla R.
5/10/2025
Stopped in after hiking at Black Bear and I had to use the restroom and was impressed the bathroom was immaculate! Ordered a Pizza Bianca, my sister ordered a pepperoni and mushroom and also a...
See a problem?
