Goodfellas Pizza

$$
Open
yelp logo

(53)

Photos

2993 S 25th St
Fort Pierce, FL 34981

Goodfellas Pizza is a restaurant that offers a variety of pizza options and some additional menu items, such as salads and calzones. Despite its name and variety, customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the quality of the food and overall dining experience. Issues noted include undercooked dishes and poor food presentation, leading to complaints about inedible meals.

The establishment has also faced criticism for its customer service, both over the phone and in person. Patrons have reported negative interactions when attempting to resolve issues with their orders, which has contributed to an overall perception of unprofessionalism. Goodfellas Pizza's reputation is marred by these experiences, reflecting a need for improvement in both food quality and service.

Generated from the web

Reviews

yelp logo
3.053 reviews
Photo of Lee W.
Lee W.
9/18/2025

Got a buffalo chicken pizza straight up. Was delivered and was good. We always order from Goodfellas. They are consistently good. (Best Italian accent) So the next you wanna get a pizza, youz...

Photo of Sherry W.
Sherry W.
8/31/2025

We ordered take out pizza and I would say it was decent but nothing great. It took awhile to get our order but in all fairness they were busy. The new location is nice and would be good to eat...

Melissa D.
11/17/2025

received cold and dry not much sauce First time ordering may given them another chance

Photo of Golden P.
Golden P.
4/4/2024

I ordered delivery the pizza was good but for some reason every time I order garlic, knots extra wet, they come extra dry.

Photo of Carrie Gene L.
Carrie Gene L.
3/17/2024

This place has the worst food ever the Service is bad and the the manager Mike is very rude. He hung up on us after telling us that they don't refund

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaFort PierceGoodfellas Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.