Giuseppe's Brooklyn Oven I

yelp logo

(9)

Photos

2135 SW Highway 17
Arcadia, FL 34266

Reviews

yelp logo
3.59 reviews
Photo of Stephanie D.
Stephanie D.
9/23/2025

Fantastic new family-owned Italian restaurant! Service was warm and attentive, and the casual atmosphere felt so welcoming. The piano playing in the background created such a great vibe and really...

Photo of KC A.
KC A.
9/14/2025

New Italian food in Arcadia and delicious. The exterior was so well landscaped, parking was confusing but the parking lot was new and big enough for plenty of cars. The interior was cute and the...

Photo of Flo V.
Flo V.
8/16/2025

New restaurant and it's our first time here. Brand new. Walking in, we were greeted by a young lady at the Hostess table. All smiles. Inside, It smelled really good but seeing the empty...

Photo of Brandon J.
Brandon J.
7/19/2025

Restaurant is relatively new. Food was amazing. Service was good. Timing was a little long but that is to be expected as they work out the kitchen and the pace of being busy. There's just some...

Photo of Wes R.
Wes R.
9/2/2025

Very clean, waitress did a good job, food was quick! Large selection of pizzas and the shrimp scampi was good. Met the owner, wry nice guy. I'm sure they have had their ups and downs but give...

Own this business?
See a problem?
United StatesFloridaArcadiaGiuseppe's Brooklyn Oven I