Gatsby's Pizza

Best pizza I've had outside of pizzerias of Ohio! A thin crust that reminds me of home and pizza we had growing up. Robynn was so kind and created a memorable experience. The Buckeye pizza was...

We absolutely are so very pleased with the new ownership and location of Gatsby's pizza. David who was managing the place made our pepperoni pizza using the original ingredients as the original...

I love this place. The owners are amazing. The food is made lovingly with care. Best thin crust pizza in Ft Myers.. Well I guess it's Bonita.. They also have homemade desserts. Super casual. They...

Gatsby's operation tonight involved a one-person operation. Only one person took the orders, prepared, served, and bussed the tables. Whew, he did a lot of work. Mrs. K, I, and two friends came...

Cute mom and pop shop, nice ambiance and staff, with good pizza (homemade tasting with a crunch) and one of the best Italian subs I've ever had. Delicious! We will be back.