Rachel M.
10/5/2025
Stopped by for pizza before the FSU game and tried the White Album Pizza. It was hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. Definitely recommend!
Gaines Street Pies
Open
(7)
Photos
104 E 6th Ave
Tallahassee, FL 32303
Gaines Street Pies, founded by local entrepreneurs Jeremy Matlow and Ryan Smith, is dedicated to crafting the best pizza in Tallahassee using only fresh ingredients. With a focus on homemade recipes, they have eliminated freezers and microwaves, creating innovative flavors that have garnered positive feedback from the community.
Since opening its first location, Gaines Street Pies has expanded to multiple venues, including Midtown and the Capital Circle, and continues to be a favorite for those seeking unique pizza experiences. Their adjoining Warhorse Whiskey Bar also provides a semi-private space for gatherings of up to 60 people, further enhancing their commitment to community dining.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
5.07 reviews
Theo F.
8/23/2025
The pizza from Gaines is great. I've only ordered for carryout, but each time from different locations. The pies were consistent between the locations. Gaines will be my pizza go to whenever in...
Leslie W.
7/14/2025
Excellent pizza. Food is phenomenal. They deliver to Ology Brewery as well! A combo made in heaven.
Melissa A.
1/23/2025
We love Gaines Street Pies! Today was the second time my husband and I have been traveling through Tallahassee that we ate here. First time we went to the Gaines St. location, but this location...
Raquel C.
5/8/2025
Pizza was better than I expected! We were passing through on a road trip and found this place service was good place was clean and pizza was good.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.