Der Dutchman

$$
Open
yelp logo

(716)

Photos

3713 Bahia Vista St
Sarasota, FL 34232
Stop by any time of day for a lovely, scratch-made breakfast, lunch or dinner, including mouth-watering favorites like slow-roasted turkey, specialties like Tilapia and Shrimp, and Der Dutchman’s legendary pies and desserts.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0716 reviews
Photo of Connie H.
Connie H.
10/18/2025

Always love a good Amish buffet! Wait time: seated within 5 minutes Atmosphere: cozy, country restaurant, crowded and loud Service: friendly server, like any other buffet, they only come around...

Photo of Rachel M.
Rachel M.
9/6/2025

Haven't visited Der Dutchman in a while. This review is not for the restaurant. We haven't eaten here yet. This is a buffet for 19.95. We had just finished eating at Yoder's and wanted to do our...

Photo of Daniella S.
Daniella S.
8/27/2025

Good ole heart attack fatty comfort food. It's Cracker Barrel Amish style. Commercial sheen to it so that it could be an Applebees. The gift shop of quilts isn't home made, so there's that....

Photo of Heather B.
Heather B.
11/30/2025

We drove over 2 hours from Orlando to check this place out. The front of house staff was very distracted and not welcoming, with the MoD very off-putting after I found hair in my food and she told...

Photo of Stephen R.
Stephen R.
11/10/2025

Stopped in for lunch. The wait staff was very nice. Got the Cod sandwich which seemed like it was made fresh and not a frozen reheat. The fish was a little mushy. Cole slaw was the side and it...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaSarasotaDer Dutchman

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.