Hiram M.
9/16/2025
I have ordered in the past however had stopped going since I had not found that the pizza crust and ingredients lived up to my expectations. I gave them another try this week and they definitely...
Coast To Coast Pizza Company
$
Closed
(137)
Photos
61 53rd Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
Coast To Coast Pizza Company in Marathon, FL is a local and veteran-owned family pizza shop known for their handmade pizzas crafted by certified pizzaiolos using the New York Watermaker, top-quality ingredients, and delicious toppings.
Whether you're in the mood for a slice or a whole pie, this pizzeria takes pride in serving their community and visitors with mouthwatering pizzas while also supporting the local SPCA of the Florida Keys in finding forever homes for sheltered animals.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5137 reviews
Paul S.
7/4/2025
After a long day of eating and drinking on marathon key I was of course exhausted and needed a large pie. I found Coast to Coast pizza, which being on the key is like 1 mile from coast to coast,...
Amanda S.
2/12/2025
My family ordered a pizza and a salad for pick up from Coast to Coast while vacationing in Marathon. We did a margherita pizza and greek salad- both were delicious! I would very much recommend...
J J.
12/29/2024
I'm giving one star here, we were on our way out of the keys and hungry. Took 45 minutes to get the pie and upon picking up my second slice I found a FOUND A HAIR... a light wavy one. GROSS. We...
Mark P.
11/30/2024
Good quality pizza here and believe it or not, solid Key Lime pie. Who knew? A nice thick slice, not too limey, and with real whipped cream. Nice touch. I'm honestly sick of Key Lime pie having...
See a problem?
