Caribbean Pie Company

$
Open
yelp logo

(23)

Call
Website

Photos

2245 Bee Ridge Rd
Sarasota, FL 34239
+1 (941) 882-4589
https://www.caribbeanpieco.com

The Caribbean Pie Company, located in Sarasota, Florida, is renowned for their famous Key Lime Pie on a Stick, voted 'Best Pie' in Sarasota in 2022. They offer a variety of delicious pies, including Classic Key Lime Pie, Apple Crumb Pie, Southern Pecan Pie, and Traditional Pumpkin Pie, all made with high-quality ingredients and baked to perfection.

In addition to their mouthwatering pies, the Caribbean Pie Company also offers gift certificates and pie delivery services, making it easy to surprise friends and family with a delectable treat. For special events and parties, customers can rent their lightweight cart, filled with Key Lime Pie-on-a-Stick and Mini-Pies, ensuring a delightful and refreshing experience for all attendees.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.523 reviews
Photo of Rachel M.
Rachel M.
8/25/2021

Amazing key lime pies and other wonderful pies served with a smile. Came here because I saw them once at the Farmers Market at Lakewood Ranch on Sundays. The tropical key lime pie screamed my...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Molly R.
Molly R.
4/24/2025

Unreal. So delicious. If you're gluten free you have to try this pie, it's so nice to have options and the ability to have a tasty dessert. We grabbed this at the Venice market. The service was...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Alex M.
Alex M.
4/15/2023

Delicious pie!!! I would say the coconut one was by far my favorite! And the peanut butter one was also really good. People raved about the key lime pie there but I think I have had better other...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Linda N.
Linda N.
8/13/2023

Best food and best service! Love this company!!! Delicious fudge and pies. The young gentleman who is one of the owners of this family owned company could not be a more nice and kind person.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Richard S.
Richard S.
4/5/2021

Just as I became addicted to Key Lime Pie, Jerry talked me into trying the Peanut Butter Pie. Wow! Next time I move out of my comfort zone I will try the Nutella Pie. No matter what pie you...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Sweet Doctors
Eating places, Organic and diet food

Sweet Doctors

88
•
$
"Let me start off by saying I'm giving five stars purely based on customer service. I live out of state and ordered some cheesecake cupcakes for my friend's birthday to be delivered to her. She..."
photo of Carly A.
St Armands Baking Company
Bakery products, Pet foods, Feathers and feather products

St Armands Baking Company

$
St. Armands Baking Company, located in Bradenton, Florida, has been a leader in producing high-quality fresh baked bread, rolls, and buns for over 30 years. Their state-of-the-art manufacturing facility produces millions of pounds of various bread products annually, adhering to the highest food safety standards recognized worldwide. Committed to excellence, St. Armands Baking Company offers a wide range of products, including artisan breads, hamburger buns, and custom baking services. They also provide both fresh and frozen delivery options across several locations in Florida, ensuring convenient access to their extensive product line. Generated from the website
Ninos Bakery & Cafe
Bakery products, General electrical contractor, Pet foods

Ninos Bakery & Cafe

95
•
$
"Oh my! Incredibly pastries and bagels. The best custard I have ever tasted in a doughnut and pastry."
United States›Florida›Sarasota›Caribbean Pie Company

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.