Cesar
9/11/2025
My wonderful daughter brought me here for my birthday and what a nice dinner we had. I ordered lasagna which was a nice size serving and delicious, she had the chicken parm and it was wonderful....
Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant
$$
Closed
(495)
Photos
69 S Palm Ave
Sarasota, FL 34236
Fine Italian food in downtown Sarasota with outdoor dining and a nostalgic bar that is family friendly. Memories are being served. Caragiulos became one of Sarasota’s most popular eateries in much the same way the family found the cozy storefront on Palm Avenue, with… ease. From his bakery in Brooklyn, Tony Caragiulo and his five sons came to Florida in pursuit of an agreeable location to open a simple Italian restaurant. After an exhausting, two week long car trek around Florida with no prospects and tempers flaring, Tony signaled for the car to pull over; “Stoppa the*#!*#!!!!car!,… This is it,” he declared, pointing to the vacant stucco location… And it was.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0495 reviews
Marion H.
8/24/2025
Sooo Caragiulo's Italian American was on my list for our Sarasota visit and I'm glad we went. I love some good Italian food, and they did not disappoint. The restaurant had that classic Italian...
Brett T.
9/25/2025
Huge disappointment. Went to Caraguilo's about a year ago and everything was amazing: food, service, atmosphere, etc. Been wanting to go back but just hadn't gotten around to it until last night....
Angela C.
10/10/2025
Our bartender was great. The bar was quiet which I love. Tiramisu was fluffy and so good. I'll be back when they reopen.
Nidhi P.
12/5/2024
We loved the house bread. It was the best!! Especially with chilli oil that's on the table. I'm so glad it's vegan. Also appreciate the vegan options, we got the mushroom pizza. The leeks were a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.