W. Paige O.
11/14/2025
We live near Brooklyn Boys Pizza & get take out regularly for years now. Gosh how lucky we are to have such REAL food in our small community! Everything here is amazing from the Pizza to the...
Brooklyn Boys
$
Closed
(107)
Photos
205 NE Commercial Cir
Keystone Heights, FL 32656
Brooklyn Boys, a family-owned establishment, serves up mouth-watering Italian cuisine in Keystone Heights, FL. Originally established in Lake City in 2007, the restaurant was founded by Nick Tonetti, who honed his culinary skills in New York under renowned chefs and restaurant owners.
Specializing in homemade Italian meals and daily specials for lunch, Brooklyn Boys offers an authentic dining experience for dinner, featuring a variety of traditional dishes and their renowned pizza. The restaurant also hosts events throughout the year, providing a welcoming space for music, friendship, and celebration.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5107 reviews
Shay V.
9/6/2025
Brooklyn Boys has a great atmosphere overall, with cool décor, indoor and outdoor seating, and fans or heaters depending on the weather. The food is usually very flavorful with fresh ingredients,...
Tim F.
9/21/2024
Been in KH for a year and finally have this place a shot. Decor is defo as described by others as Politically Incorrect, but I don't base my food options on politics, so not bothered. Mama and I...
Ed S.
1/17/2025
Atmosphere is pretty plain and our waitress was brand new but had a great attitude and worked hard to make up for her lack of experience but... went in with a party of twenty (they don't take...
Jessica K.
10/7/2025
Food takes too long. We can make one at home and have it eaten before one even makes it to our table at this establishment. Last time it took 45 minutes to get a large pizza brought to our table...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.