Bokeelia M.
4/9/2012
My husband, son and I stopped at the NEW fish stop restaurant recently and WOW!! It was not only fantastic, but reasonably priced too. My husband enjoyed their island famous softshell crab...
Barnhill Seafood Market & More
$$
Open
(20)
Photos
4573 Pine Island Rd NW
Cape Coral, FL 33993
Barnhill Seafood Market & More is a family-owned and operated seafood market located in the heart of Matlacha, Florida. With three generations of experience in the fishing industry, the Barnhill clan has established a proud tradition of providing fresh seafood to the local community. Their retail market offers a wide selection of fresh seafood, including stone crab claws, live blue crab, mullet, oysters, clams, Gulf shrimp, and various Gulf and Atlantic fish. Visitors can also enjoy grab-and-go options like boiled shrimp, smoked mullet, mullet dip, and Karen's Key Lime Pie, a decadent island treat.
Occupying a historic fish house coated in their signature Barnhill Green color, the market is a vibrant addition to Matlacha's funky pastel palette. The building, which used to serve as a wholesale seafood hub, now caters exclusively to retail customers. Open Tuesday to Saturday, Barnhill Seafood Market & More is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers looking for fresh, locally sourced options in Matlacha.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.520 reviews
Daren R.
1/30/2025
The beautiful multi-colored wall mural paintings were inviting. Walking up the big cement steps added a nostalgic, old school feel. The mound of red snapper on ice was eye-catching, with its...
Jerry M.
12/14/2024
Dependably fresh and quality seafood and service. I have known the family for 40 plus years and have never been disappointed when dealing with them. Great people run a great business serving SW...
Al B.
3/18/2025
Authentic seafood available right near the docks. Freshest fish - cleaned and ready to cook, as well as some house-smoked fillets - and the best key lime pie I have ever eaten! Well worth the trip!
Maria V.
9/28/2023
Love the key lime pie and stone crabs! Always fresh. Always friendly! There aren't many places on the island that we can buy fresh seafood from.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.