Super Real life Mario bros
5/3/2025
Service was fast zippy to the point friendly nice atmosphere nice looking place not very dirty very clean place with friendly staff and lots of options for bagels etc, I got the plain bagel with...
Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe
$
Closed
(88)
Photos
205 Key Deer Blvd
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe, located in Big Pine Key, FL, is a local favorite offering a wide range of freshly made New York-style bagels, delicious Cuban coffee, and a variety of pastries. Known for its hearty breakfast and lunch options, the shop takes pride in providing a cozy atmosphere where customers can enjoy made-to-order sandwiches and flavorful desserts.
The menu features an array of breakfast items, including omelets and waffles, alongside a selection of sandwiches such as the Cuban and Reuben. With a commitment to quality ingredients and a diverse beverage menu, Bagel Island ensures that every visit is a delightful experience for both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.088 reviews
Sydney D.
9/5/2025
First time in the keys and friend decided to bring me here and it did not disappoint! Bagels were fluffy and buttery and the eggs, meat, and cheese complimented it perfectly. The service was...
Amy P.
4/17/2025
Stopped by for breakfast/lunch on the way up from Key West. I got an egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on an onion bagel. The food was hot and fresh and the bagel was nice and soft. Also tried an...
Noel J.
8/9/2024
Stopped here for a quick bite while on the way to Key West! This is a cute bagel store with a nice assortment of bagel flavors, sandwiches, drinks and more. The food is reasonably priced and the...
James T.
4/28/2025
Food was good and tasty. Service was annoyed we hadn't memorized the chalkboard menu nor could see it 25feet away.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.