Marc G.
5/31/2020
It's a dive ... but in a good way. The seafood is local (except where they expressly state so, like their salmon), extremely fresh, and reasonably priced. We got 2 lbs of local shrimp. We steamed...
Atlantic Seafood
$$
Closed
(27)
Photos
10 Ash St
Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Atlantic Seafood Market, located in Old Saybrook, Connecticut, has been a beloved seafood destination since 1978, known for sourcing the highest-quality and freshest seafood available. Under the ownership of Lisa Feinman and the culinary expertise of CIA-trained chef Jerry Doran, all dishes are prepared from scratch daily, ensuring a commitment to freshness and flavor without artificial additives.
Recognized as a top seafood market through various accolades and features in prominent publications, Atlantic Seafood offers a diverse menu that includes gourmet seafood meals, soups, and salads tailored for every palate. Its dedication to sustainable practices and local sourcing sets it apart from larger chain competitors, making it a staple for seafood lovers in the region.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.027 reviewsKathy G.
5/10/2025
Did not smell like fish at all the building smelled of rot. the fish itself is clearly flaking despite "being cut same day" so i cant possibly trust that this is fresh.
AL K.
8/12/2021
Came to buy some fresh seafood as their ad would say. Sadly there were only shrimps and some cut of fish. Expected more but was let down.
Tim S.
10/30/2023
Tends to sell out of the fresh fish options but found out that if you give them your name, they will at least try to save some for you. The fresh tuna was absolutely amazing - we used for sashimi...
Finiky F.
8/29/2019
OMG fresh grouper filleted that morning and i was there at 9 am on my way back to Atlanta. Super nice fellows and there was at least 5 guys hanging out! Wow seafood is so adulterated and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.