Antonella's Pizzeria

$
Closed
yelp logo

(392)

Photos

360 W Fairbanks Ave
Winter Park, FL 32789
Welcome to Antonella’s Pizzeria. We are a family owned & operated pizza shop that offers local, fresh, traditional new york-style pizza and delicious Italian food. Our hand spun pizza dough is made daily on the premises, along with fresh homemade sauces and entrees. We have served Central Florida great Italian food for over twenty years and have done so with an impeccable reputation. We have owned and managed small pizzerias to larger Italian restaurants, anywhere from downtown Orlando to East Orlando. Throughout the many years of hard work in this business, we have learned one very important secret to success, that size does not matter (for once) nor does its location or name of restaurant……..its how you treat your guests and quality of food that you serve your guests. Our promise is simple; treat our guests like our family! Our small location is limited seating and we will strive on take out and delivery. Whether catering an office party for lunch or ordering a fresh pizza for your family for dinner, we want to be your go-to Pizzeria for any occasion. Lets keep the local family restaurants alive for generations to come.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5392 reviews
Photo of Corrina Q.
Corrina Q.
7/11/2025

The other day I was craving a big, meaty, cheesy, lasagna. I don't usually get Italian food to-go, but my brain was telling me that I NEEDED IT IMMEDIATELY. My boyfriend and I looked around on...

Photo of Jasmine J.
Jasmine J.
3/3/2025

I don't think I've been to Antonella's since pre-pandemic, and I'm happy to report that not a thing has changed! We went on a Saturday afternoon and they weren't super busy. Since it's a small mom...

Photo of Nicole S.
Nicole S.
11/24/2024

I've been going to Antonella's for over a year. I noticed at one point the pizza quality just wasn't the same, so I took a break. However, now the pizza quality seems to be better then ever! They...

Photo of Michael L.
Michael L.
5/6/2025

This is my $36, extra crispy, 16" pizza from Antonella's. This pizza has $4 worth of pepperoni (22 pieces) , $4 worth of mushrooms (several slices have none and about 20 full slices accounted...

Photo of Jose P.
Jose P.
8/13/2024

Well, I work in downtown Winter Park and really wanted a Calzone today. I already tried one from another Pizza place nearby, but it was not good. And definitely worth the price. So I gave these...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaWinter ParkAntonella's Pizzeria

Partial Data by Foursquare.