Sherry W.
7/27/2025
I love Key Lime pie and order it most times it is offered on a menu. I have spent a lot in Florida and had many variations. So when I saw this offering at a Farmers Market I was curious. The...
Coastal Key Lime Pie
Closed
(13)
Photos
19563 Coastal Hwy
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971
Coastal Key Lime Pie, based in Seaford, Delaware, offers handcrafted key lime pies that embody the essence of coastal flavors. Each pie is made with love, using a perfected recipe and the finest ingredients, delivering a delightful balance of tangy and sweet in every bite.
Dedicated to sustainability, the company employs eco-friendly packaging, ensuring that their indulgent desserts not only taste amazing but also support ocean conservation efforts. Customers can enjoy a slice of beach bliss whether enjoyed fresh or frozen, making it a perfect treat for any occasion.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
5.013 reviews
Christine J.
9/9/2025
Absolutely delicious key lime pie shop. They only offer slices, pies, and chocolate dipped slices. Definitely worth the stop if you're in the area.
Shannon S.
8/20/2025
I love pie and particularly Key Lime pie. I was a little reluctant to nab from a food cart, but WOW, so glad I did. Perfect tartness, excellent crust, and too notch creaminess. I wish I bought the...
Steve I.
6/29/2025
Absolutely the best key lime pie outside of Florida keys. Service at the roadside truck friendly. These pies are worth the trip to Rehoboth. They also have an excellent gluten free option for...
Claudia L.
5/20/2025
The most perfect key lime pie! I've wanted to try Coastal's pies for a while now (I visit the area once or twice a year) and finally got my chance to do so - well worth the wait! (insert all the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.