Ian W.
9/17/2022
The Plum Tomato opened their East Lyme location in the former Yummy Yummy Pizza. I looked over their menu earlier on the ToastTab online ordering system, but they stopped accepting online orders...
The Plum Tomato
$
Open
(16)
Photos
10 Chesterfield Rd
East Lyme, CT 06333
The Plum Tomato strives to serve our customers food that is of the highest quality. All of our dishes are made in house from scratch and we pride ourselves in staying true to that. We also strive to cater to all dietary needs so that everyone has something to enjoy!
Also at this address
Reviews
3.516 reviews
Silvia S.
6/16/2025
Don't order a salad. They don't wash their salad there was dirt on all over. This is the second time this has happened.
Ken A.
3/8/2023
Nice clean restaurant qith easy ordering. Either online, in person or on the phone. We used the online ordering. Simple, menu was clear to understand with all the options. Sizes for pizza...
Corinne Z.
1/23/2024
Second visit. First visit we just had slices of pizza. So dry and hard crust couldn't be bent for eating. This time ordered an entire large pizza. Unbelievably thin cracker like crust that...
Laureen W.
9/22/2024
Just picked up a slice and a sandwich.. Pizza was pretty good. However I was pretty disappointed with the sandwich when I got home. Never have I seen a restaurant put 1slice of salami on a...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.