Pennywise Consignment Shop

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(34)

Call
Website

Photos

22 Greenmanville Ave
Mystic, CT 06355
+1 (860) 572-9232
http://www.pennywisemystic.com

Pennywise Consignment Shop, located near Mystic Seaport on Greenmanville Avenue, offers a wide selection of men's and women's new and consigned clothing, including shoes, scarves, bags, and jewelry from various name brands. The store caters to diverse style preferences, offering clothing ranging from casual wear to business attire and evening wear.

In addition to their main location, Pennywise also operates Pennywise Downtown, a children's and adult's consignment store in downtown Mystic, providing a convenient shopping option for local residents and visitors. With both stores open seven days a week, customers can easily explore and find unique pieces to add to their wardrobe.

Generated from their available business information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.034 reviews
Photo of Kristen B.
Kristen B.
8/7/2025

Great little shop. I found some nice, name-brand clothes in nearly new condition for very reasonable prices

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Vivian G.
Vivian G.
7/14/2025

The best thrift store in this town, with lots of clothes, handbags, THE SHOES OMG (got a pair) Lots of named brands items like Michael Kors, Kate Spade, and entire table of Tory Burch, I spent...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Alejandra P.
Alejandra P.
1/18/2025

Came here exploring Mystic and found one thing I liked but it was extremely overpriced for a used consignment store. Some items are new but some are used and can definitely be dropped down in...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Tiffanie S.
Tiffanie S.
7/30/2024

Love this store! Very neatly organized with something for everyone. Excellent handbag and Lilly Pulitzer collection. Hit them up when they have a sale, $3 for a basically brand new summer top!...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Adam D.
Adam D.
1/27/2025

This place is great - I have been to Pennywise many times as a consignor and shopper. The 50/50 split is more than fair to not have the hassle of selling leftover name brand clothes on eBay or...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Savvy Swap Consignment
Women's specialty clothing stores, Services, nec, nec, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Savvy Swap Consignment

12
•
$$
"100/10 recommend this store. I am not much of a shopper and I was panicked to find a dress to wear to a wedding in a week. I can't say enough about the owner who not only helped me select the..."
Women's specialty clothing stores, Custom and orthopedic shoes, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Act II

4
•
$$$
"Really great treasures to be had here. Priscilla (shop owner)is friendly, knowledgeable and very helpful with selection of merchandise. I have not experienced the hours issues that some other..."
photo of Michael S.
Again and Again
Women's specialty clothing stores, Office furniture and store fixtures, secondhand

Again and Again

4
"Spent the day thrift shopping and unfortunately Again and Again was our final stop so we had only 1/2hr. Could have spent hours in here! Wide variety of clothing, lots of beachy vibing outfits..."
photo of Bre B.
United States›Connecticut›Mystic›Pennywise Consignment Shop

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.