Jackie M.
10/9/2025
Hands down, it may not physically be IN New Haven, but their brick oven pizza (especially their pepperoni) is phenomenal!! I recommend them highly. If dining in, the staff is top-notch and very...
New Haven Pizza Place
$
Closed
(108)
Photos
1377 New Haven Ave
Milford, CT 06460
New Haven Pizza Place is a Milford-based pizzeria that specializes in serving authentic New Haven style pizza, cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. With a passion for brick ovens and a love for pizza, this newly opened establishment aims to bring the delicious flavors of New Haven to the local community and beyond.
Using only the finest ingredients and traditional techniques, New Haven Pizza Place is dedicated to delivering a mouthwatering pizza experience that will satisfy even the most discerning pizza lovers. Stay tuned to their Facebook Page for updates on their restaurant and seasonal specials as they continue to delight customers throughout the holiday season.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0108 reviews
Marie R.
9/22/2025
Phenomenal calzone served in 30 minutes. It was worth the wait . We had the eggplant and ricotta calzone which was a very good size portion. The restaurant is clean, has an extensive menu and...
Ryan C.
9/14/2025
The first time we went to New Haven Pizza Place over a year ago, part of the bottom was burned. Not just the "char" but burned. Still edible, but importantly, the flavor was very good. And the...
Krista F.
11/9/2025
Pizza is great was so yummy 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 mozzarella . Salad sucked . Beers good .
Angel B.
3/11/2025
Tuesday night trivia night in the bar area. Place was packed! Servers were harried but so, so pleasant! We had wings, pizza and a pasta dinner and everything came out quick and good. Come and stop in!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.