Lisa G.
7/9/2022
This is the second Mystic Pizza, the first being in Mystic, CT. The nostalgia that can be seen in the first Mystic Pizza is not as immersive here in North Stonington. The pizza however is just...
Mystic Pizza
(14)
Photos
North Stonington, CT 06359
Mystic Pizza is a quaint eatery in North Stonington, CT, known for serving up a variety of pizzas and other Italian dishes.
With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, this establishment offers a casual dining experience for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
3.514 reviews
Teresa W.
10/22/2024
I enjoyed Mystic Pizza so much! I had wanted to come here since 1988 and it didn't disappoint. The pizza was delish, customer service was great and the ambiance was just as expected! It's a must...
Jeanmarie M.
1/6/2025
I wish I liked the pizza better here. Unfortunately, it is too thick and greasy for me. The grinders here are very good, and I like the two options for bread (soft or crunchy with sesame). I do...
T. P.
8/18/2024
Always great service & pizza-kid friendly! This is our go to neighborhood pizza spot.
Gabrielle S.
1/11/2023
Great vibes, friendly staff, excellent service, and yummy pizza. It's definitely not the BEST pizza I've ever had, but taking into account the downtown area and history of the restaurant it makes...
See a problem?
