Von D.
6/8/2025
Traveling from PA to NH and needed to find a place to stop for an early dinner. Found this place on Yelp and was only 5 minutes off route. Wow! Everything about this place was awesome! It's...
Good Old Days Pizza
$
Closed
(122)
Photos
19 Main St
Newtown, CT 06470
Good Old Days Pizza is a casual dining establishment located in the basement dungeon at 19 Main Street in Newtown, CT. The restaurant operates on a first-come, first-serve basis, offering both dine-in and take-out options without reservations.
In addition to their pizza menu, Good Old Days Pizza features a lively atmosphere with music on Fridays and a happy hour from Monday to Saturday. Guests can enjoy $5 draft beers and glasses of wine all day on Sundays, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5122 reviews
Michaela P.
6/24/2025
Really solid pizza with a strong sense of identity. The space leans full nostalgia as the name suggests, with its VHS tapes on the walls, retro artwork, and just the right amount of kitsch to feel...
Antonio S.
6/5/2025
Another great dinner at Good Old Days Pizza. Working my thru all the pies so far are all very good. Service always excellent . And a great selection of tap beer.
Jason P.
6/16/2024
They don't call it Detroit Style on the menu. But Good Old Days Pizza in Newtown makes the best CT Detroit Style I've had anyway. So many Foodies rave about Good Old Days. I've wanted their...
Leah S.
12/29/2024
Was crushed when we had friends drive out to try the Tommy and Dill pizza but we were pleasantly surprised by the Supersize Me and Spicy Italy pies!! The spicy vodka sauce on the Spicy Italy pies...
See a problem?
