Rob S.
10/17/2025
I've been looking for a reason to visit Gaetano's for over two years. I live far north, but have studied their website and social media posts. Today was the day. Simply Amazing! I'm a North...
Gaetano's Deli
Permanently closed
(91)
Photos
110 Commerce Dr
Shelton, CT 06484
Gaetano's Deli, a renowned Italian delicatessen and caterer, has been serving the community in Connecticut since 1997, drawing inspiration from their roots on Arthur Avenue in The Bronx. With locations in Stratford, Westport, and Shelton, the deli has earned accolades, including being named the Number One Deli in Connecticut by Food Network and various local publications.
Founded by Guy and Milanno, Gaetano's Deli prides itself on delivering authentic Italian flavors and high-quality offerings to its loyal customers. Over the years, they have cultivated a reputation for excellence, thanks to their dedication to the craft of traditional delicatessen fare.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.091 reviews
Jay S.
12/21/2024
Once you step into Gaetano's, you'll be enveloped in the authentic charm of Arthur Avenue. This deli is a treasure of authentic Italian delights, offering a wide array of delectable...
Roman P.
4/24/2025
This place is probably the best hoagie in lower Fairfield county. If I lived closer I would visit this place far more often. Try it out, you won't regret it! Service is great as well, the little...
Madeline A.
12/30/2024
Haven't had a sandwich here in years, stopped in on Xmas Eve and it's still superior! The Kovacs is amazing! Fresh chicken cutlet and mozzarella! The customer service is also top notch! They were...
Chris S.
8/10/2025
We ordered a 1/2 tray of buffalo chicken and 1 order of broccoli rabe bread yesterday. The bread was burnt. The Buffalo chicken very disappointed. It was breaded chicken pieces with some buffalo...
See a problem?
