Jason P.
9/1/2025
I'm not sure I have the story right, but it seems like Fenwick Ice Cream moved across the street from it's old location. I'm guessing from some limited information that the at least some of the...
Fenwick Ice Cream
Closed
(30)
Photos
855 Boston Post Rd
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Fenwick Ice Cream Co. calls Old Saybrook, CT, home. Crafting their delectable treats by hand for more than three decades, this charming spot takes pride in serving up award-winning ice cream that has clinched the title of “Best Made Ice Cream in CT” four times according to Connecticut Magazine.
Set in the heart of Old Saybrook, Fenwick Ice Cream Co. stands as a beloved local gem. With a legacy of creating artisanal ice cream, this establishment continues to delight visitors with its flavorful creations, showcasing the dedication and passion that goes into every scoop.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.530 reviews
Casey G.
7/30/2025
Love that Fenwick offers a couple of vegan ice cream options. I ordered a black raspberry chocolate chip vegan ice cream and a pup cup. The black raspberry was not the best I've had but it was...
Monica B.
5/25/2025
I was told they have a new location but the same good ice cream ! Congrats! No worries, I will return! :)
Cindy B.
7/27/2025
The best coconut ice cream I have had!!!! It has the perfect amount of sweetness and the coconut shavings were amazing! I would drive to Old Saybrook just for the coconut ice cream, a 1.5 hour...
Allison C.
7/20/2024
We couldn't resist getting some ice cream from Fenwick after having lunch at Johnny Ad's! They have a bunch of flavors to choose from, and all of the ice cream is handmade by them. We indulged in...
See a problem?
