Emily T.
8/16/2025
This review is for the Milford food truck at 499 New Haven Avenue. It's so good to see the old Sundae House lot busy with patrons for this amazing truck. Service was prompt and friendly. Shout...
Cookie39
Open
(16)
Photos
39 Broadway
New Haven, CT 06511
Cookie Thirty Nine is a family-oriented cookie shop located in New Haven, Connecticut, offering a diverse selection of cookies, each crafted with unique flavors and stories. Their commitment to community support ensures that every purchase contributes to local causes, while their cookies are baked from scratch daily for unbeatable freshness.
Combining gourmet taste with a comforting, home-style feel, Cookie Thirty Nine invites customers to indulge in their delicious offerings and explore their apparel collection. The shop also features a stunning mural, making it a perfect spot for memorable selfies and a delightful cookie experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.516 reviews
Shelley C.
10/28/2025
The cookie was delicious and big! The coffee was just lukewarm. And the price is very expensive. For a cookie and coffee it came to over eight dollars. There is no senior discount! It's a bit...
Mark N.
10/30/2025
Large warm excellent cookies (haven't had the ice cream one yet)! Expensive, but 3 cookies when you buy 2, 2-4 in the afternoon. If you know cookies like I know cookies, this is the place!
Marie R.
8/13/2024
Cookie 39 is truly a sweet treat and a wonderful addition to the neighborhood.The aroma as you enter the beautiful brand new facility was mesmerizing and completely irresistible. The manager...
Shanina S.
8/12/2024
Cookie 39 is a new cookie establishment located in the heart of the Yale University area. As soon as I walked in the establishment it was very clean and smelled like an abundance of cookies. As I...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.