Bee W.
10/31/2025
I love the pizza here and the server/supervisor gal. She's always nice to us. They have less seating now due to continued staffing challenges. I'm sad about that because they have amazing pizza....
Stumpy's New York Style Pizza
$
Closed
(196)
Photos
138 S Wilcox St
Castle Rock, CO 80104
Stumpy's New York Style Pizza is dedicated to bringing authentic New York-style pizza to Castle Rock, Colorado. With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, they aim to deliver a true taste of New York in every slice.
In addition to their signature pizzas, Stumpy's offers a variety of other delicious Italian dishes, ensuring that there's something for everyone. Their inviting atmosphere and commitment to customer satisfaction make them a popular choice for both residents and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Find related places
Reviews
3.5196 reviews
JT C.
7/11/2025
Some of the best NY style pizza in CO. You have to eat it fresh, and you have to order double toppings- wait staff is amazing, super friendly, and quick! Lots of places claim to have NY pizza, as...
Jimmy H.
3/1/2025
Excellent hidden little gem for some good NY style pizza. Wings are excellent as well. They also have pinball and a cool dark atmosphere in there if I still drank this would be my bar.
Rose O.
8/16/2024
Pizza was good but nothing special, the service was horrible. Not enough staff! Our pizza took almost 1 hour from the time we ordered to the time we were served. Our waitress walked by several...
Ashley K.
9/13/2024
I am obsessed with the pizza here. It's probably my favorite spot in castle rock! The service can be a little slow but it's worth it to me. It's just a quality hole in the wall bar!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.