Misty P.
7/2/2022
Incredible wings! So these may very well be the best wings I've ever had. I ordered 6 Mango Habanero wings. I think they deep fried the wings. The skin had a nice crunch and while the meat itself...
New York Pizza
Closed
(16)
Photos
901 Highway 133
Carbondale, CO 81623
New York Pizza is a popular pizza joint located in Carbondale, CO, offering a variety of delicious food options including beer, salads, sandwiches, wings, and of course, pizza.
With three convenient locations in Aspen, Basalt, and Carbondale, New York Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike, providing a satisfying dining experience with their mouthwatering menu.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.516 reviewsJordan M.
7/26/2025
The only thing saving this place is the food. Instead of taking accountability and saying they missed my FIRST doordash ticket. I overhear the worker blaming me for placing two orders. Sorry, but...
N P.
7/26/2025
This wasn't the absolute worst pizza I've ever had, but it's very close. Crust was lackluster and I ended up getting a pizza that was almost all raw onions. Other toppings were sparse and the...
Stefanie S.
12/2/2023
A solid neighborhood spot with good food, friendly staff, cold drinks and 10 TVs for all the games! Who could ask for more?
Scott A.
11/5/2023
Outstanding Food , great prices & the service could not have been better . Ill come back with some football friends to watch a game . The pizza and wings were great and the beer selection was...
See a problem?
